By David Benatar

Higher by no means to were argues for a couple of similar, hugely provocative, perspectives: (1) entering lifestyles is usually a major damage. (2) it really is constantly mistaken to have young ones. (3) it truly is improper to not abort fetuses on the past phases of gestation. (4) it'd be larger if, due to there being no new humans, humanity turned extinct. those perspectives could sound unbelievable--but someone who reads Benatar should be obliged to take them heavily.

Show description

Read Online or Download Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence PDF

Best ethics books

Some We Love, Some We Hate, Some We Eat: Why It's So Hard to Think Straight About Animals

Combining the mind of Malcolm Gladwell with the irreverent humor of Mary Roach and the paradigm-shifting research of Jared Diamond, a number one social scientist deals an unparalleled glance within our complicated and infrequently paradoxical relationships with animals.

Does dwelling with a puppy particularly make humans happier and fitter? What will we study from biomedical study with mice? Who loved a greater caliber of life—the poultry on a dinner plate or the hen who died in a Saturday-night cockfight? Why is it fallacious to consume the relatives puppy? Drawing on greater than 20 years of study within the rising box of anthrozoology, the technology of human–animal kinfolk, Hal Herzog deals astounding solutions to those and different questions concerning the ethical conundrums we are facing day in and time out concerning the creatures with whom we proportion our international.

a few we adore, a few We Hate, a few We devour is a hugely interesting and illuminating trip during the complete spectrum of human–animal kin, according to Dr. Herzog’s groundbreaking learn on animal rights activists, cockfighters, specialist dog-show handlers, veterinary scholars, and biomedical researchers. mixing anthropology, behavioral economics, evolutionary psychology, and philosophy, Herzog conscientiously crafts a continuing narrative enriched with real-life anecdotes, medical learn, and his personal experience of ethical ambivalence.

Alternately poignant, demanding, and laugh-out-loud humorous, this enlightening and provocative publication will endlessly swap the way in which we glance at our relations with different creatures and, eventually, how we see ourselves.

Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals (Rethinking the Western Tradition)

"Lara Denis's refined updating of Thomas Abbott's classical translation of Kant's basis for the Metaphysics of Morals could be the top for either scholars and common readers. Her transparent and concise creation highlights Kant's valuable claims and arguments whereas pointing the reader to the easiest of up to date Kant scholarship.

Animal Rights and Moral Philosophy

Animals evidently can't have a correct of loose speech or a correct to vote simply because they lack the correct capacities. yet their correct to existence and to be freed from exploitation isn't any much less basic than the corresponding correct of people, writes Julian H. Franklin. This theoretically rigorous e-book will reassure the devoted, aid the doubtful to make your mind up, and arm the polemicist.

Charity: The Place of the Poor in the Biblical Tradition

It has lengthy been stated that Jews and Christians individual themselves via charity to the poor. Though historic Greeks and Romans have been additionally beneficiant, they funded theaters and baths instead of poorhouses and orphanages. How may perhaps we clarify this difference? In this important reappraisal of charity within the biblical culture, Gary Anderson argues that the bad constituted the privileged position the place Jews and Christians met God.

Extra resources for Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence

Sample text

The analysis of the cheerful is mistaken for a number of reasons: First, it makes the wrong comparison. If we want to determine whether non-existence is preferable to existence, or vice versa, then we must compare the left- and the right-hand sides of the diagram, which represent the alternative scenarios in which X exists and in which X never exists. Comparing the upper and the lower quadrants on the left does not tell us whether Scenario A is better than Scenario B or vice versa. That is unless quadrants () and () are rendered irrelevant.

In such cases the choice will be between bringing a defective child into existence or bringing a healthy, but different, child into existence. ⁶ For a defence of the use of this pronoun see Benatar, David, ‘Sexist Language: Alternatives to the Alternatives’, Public Affairs Quarterly, / () –. ⁷ The example is Derek Parfit’s. See his Reasons and Persons, . Why Coming into Existence Is Always a Harm ∼  Whereas the claim that coming into existence is always a harm runs counter to most (but not all) people’s intuitions, the claim that coming into existence in the aforementioned cases is a harm accords very well with popular intuition.

We may not know who that person would have been, but we can still say that whoever that person would have been, the avoidance of his or her pains is good when judged in terms of his or her potential interests. If there is any (obviously loose) sense in which the absent pain is good for the person who could have existed but does not exist, this is it. ²³ In support of the asymmetry between () and (), it can be shown that it has considerable explanatory power. It explains at least four other asymmetries that are quite plausible.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.23 of 5 – based on 26 votes